Uncommon Thrift Celebrates 50 Years

CHATHAM – Tucked behind the hustle and bustle of downtown Chatham, an uncommon thrifting experience awaits the eager shopper searching for their next unexpected treasure. And this year, that shop is celebrating its 50th anniversary helping people find their new favorite item.

For half a century, Uncommon Thrift, run by St. Christopher’s Episcopal Church, has been more than just a place to browse for bargains — it’s been a town fixture. Steadfast volunteers, generous donors and curious customers have kept it thriving, ensuring it continues to serve the community it calls home.

While stores like Uncommon Thrift have been around since the late 19th century, with Goodwill Industries first established in the United States in 1902, they have seen a recent rise in popularity — one that is likely to continue. According to PBS, the secondhand clothing industry is projected to grow about three times faster than the overall apparel market. 

These stores are especially popular with Gen Z, with many thrift stores going viral on social media platforms like Instagram and TikTok for their funky styles and one-of-a-kind pieces.

But Uncommon Thrift isn’t only for younger generations. According to Manager Louise Montross, the shop is a “curated collection” where pieces are chosen to fit the ever-changing needs of local shoppers and include fine china, furniture and, of course, clothing.

The store opened in 1975 as St. Christopher’s Thrift and Gift Shop, designed to help fund the building of a new chapel and parish hall. Over the years it underwent many changes, including moves in 1979 and 2009 and a re-naming in 2021.

In 2020, according to Montross, Uncommon Thrift made the decision to discontinue consignment to reflect current trends and give the shop a contemporary look.

Today, the approximately 1,000-square-foot shop boasts a handpicked array of donated items ready for the next buyer to cherish —- from Burberry belts to Waterford Crystal, to Kate Spade accessories and even local art. The fall collection is just starting, with cashmere sweaters, silk scarves and more. 

Montross said none of the store’s success would have been possible without the support of its volunteers. With over 45 helpers this summer, Montross said she was proud to be a part of the team.

 “It’s nice going into the 50th year as successful as we are. Everyone’s working together to make this place run,” she said, adding that “It’s a very lovely group.”

All proceeds continue to benefit the St. Christopher’s Church outreach programs and operations, including Lower Cape Outreach Council, the Chatham Food Pantry, Chatham Bereavement Support Group, local Pastoral Care efforts, the Goll Farm School in Liberia and internal operations. 

With 50 years of volunteers, donations and unique finds behind it, Uncommon Thrift continues to thrive as a place where a new treasure is always waiting, and where every purchase gives something back.